Original Case: 2:16-cv-13292

Sixth Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
Case #: 0:18-cv-01871
Typecivil / private / civil rights
Nature of Suit440 Civil Rights - Other Civil Rights
Case Filed:Aug 01, 2018
Terminated:Jun 10, 2020
Last checked: Friday Jun 12, 2020 3:31 AM CDT
Amicus Curiae
KAPPA DELTA PI
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
DAVID DEMING
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
CENTER FOR EDUCATIONAL EQUITY AT TEACHERS COLLEGE, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY, aka CEE
Represented By
Michael A. Rebell
Michael A. Rebell Associates
contact info
Amicus Curiae
AMERICAN COUNCIL ON THE TEACHING OF FOREIGN LANGUAGES
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
PULSE INSTITUTE
Represented By
Tina M. Patterson
The PuLSE Institute
contact info
Amicus Curiae
DAVID AUTOR
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
SARA SOLOW
Represented By
Scott Burnett Smith
Bradley, Arant, Boult & Cummings
contact info
Julian D. Miller
Forman, Watkins & Krutz LLP
contact info
Amicus Curiae
CIVIC ENGAGEMENT RESEARCH GROUP AT THE UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA - RIVERSIDE, aka CERG
Represented By
Michael A. Rebell
Michael A. Rebell Associates
contact info
Amicus Curiae
482FORWARD
Represented By
Jayesh Patel
Jayesh J. Patel
contact info
Amicus Curiae
ASSOCIATION FOR MIDDLE LEVEL EDUCATION
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
MICHIGAN EDUCATION LAW AND POLICY AND CIVIL RIGHTS PROFESSORS
Represented By
Cary S. McGehee
Pitt, McGehee, Palmer & Rivers
contact info
Amicus Curiae
MARTHA MINOW
Represented By
Nicholas Klenow
Selendy & Gay
contact info
Jessica Underwood
Selendy & Gay
contact info
Bria Delaney
Selendy & Gay
contact info
Yelena Konanova
Selendy & Gay
contact info
David S. Flugman
Selendy & Gay
contact info
Amicus Curiae
PEN AMERICA
Represented By
Michael J. Dell
Kramer, Levin, Naftalis & Frankel
contact info
Amicus Curiae
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF MICHIGAN
Represented By
Daniel S. Korobkin
American Civil Liberties Union Of Michigan
contact info
Michael Jay Steinberg
contact info
Amicus Curiae
DETROIT PUBLIC SCHOOLS COMMUNITY DISTRICT
Represented By
Jenice C. Mitchell Ford
Detroit Public Schools
contact info
Amicus Curiae
EDUCATION TRUST
Represented By
Tara Jordan Plochocki
Lewis Baach Kaufmann Middlemiss PLLC
contact info
Amicus Curiae
CITY OF DETROIT, MI
Represented By
Anton Metlitsky
O'Melveny & Myers
contact info
Amicus Curiae
RICHARD J MURNANE
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
THOMAS J. KANE
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL COUNCIL OF TEACHERS OF ENGLISH
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL COUNCIL FOR THE SOCIAL STUDIES
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL COLLABORATIVE FOR DIGITAL EQUITY
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF SECONDARY SCHOOL PRINCIPALS
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT SCHOOLS
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
LEARNING DISABILITIES ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
INTERNATIONAL LITERACY ASSOCIATION
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
EDUCATIONAL LEADERS WITHOUT BORDERS
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
AMERICAN FEDERATION OF TEACHERS, AFL-CIO
Represented By
David Strom
American Federation of Teachers
contact info
Amicus Curiae
V. CREATIVE CHANGE EDUCATIONAL SOLUTIONS
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
JESSE ROTHSTEIN
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
COUNCIL OF PARENT ATTORNEYS AND ADVOCATES
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
RUCKER JOHNSON
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
ASSOCIATION OF TEACHER EDUCATORS
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
DAVID FIGLIO
Represented By
Amanda Brooke Stubblefield
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
James E. Burke Jr.
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Bryce J. Yoder
Keating, Muething & Klekamp
contact info
Amicus Curiae
LOU FREY INSTITUTE
Represented By
Michael A. Rebell
Michael A. Rebell Associates
contact info
Amicus Curiae
CENTER FOR INFORMATION AND RESEARCH ON CIVIC LEARNING AND ENGAGEMENT, aka CIRCLE
Represented By
Michael A. Rebell
Michael A. Rebell Associates
contact info
Amicus Curiae
HOME SCHOOL LEGAL DEFENSE ASSOCIATION
Represented By
James Robert Mason III
Home School Legal Defense Association
contact info
Amicus Curiae
ALLIANCE DEFENDING FREEDOM
Represented By
Rory Thomas Gray
Alliance Defending Freedom
contact info
Michael P. Farris
Home School Legal Defense Association
contact info
Amicus Curiae
INTERNATIONAL COUNCIL OF PROFESSORS AND EDUCATIONAL LEADERSHIP
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
NATIONAL ASSOCIATION FOR MULTICULTURAL EDUCATION
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
TEACHING FOR CHANGE
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
SCHOOL SOCIAL WORK ASSOCIATION OF AMERICA
Represented By
Randall P. Ewing Jr.
Korein Tillery
contact info
Amicus Curiae
DAVID STROM
Amicus Curiae
CAMPAIGN FOR THE CIVIC MISSION OF THE SCHOOLS
Represented By
Michael A. Rebell
Michael A. Rebell Associates
contact info
Amicus Curiae
ELIZABETH BIRR MOJE, Dean of the School of Education, University of Michigan
Represented By
Steven Guggenheim
Wilson, Sonsini, Goodrich & Rosati
contact info
Adam W. Burrowbridge
Wilson, Sonsini, Goodrich & Rosati
contact info
Amicus Curiae
BARRY FRIEDMAN
Represented By
Scott Burnett Smith
Bradley, Arant, Boult & Cummings
contact info
Julian D. Miller
Forman, Watkins & Krutz LLP
contact info
Amicus Curiae
PAMELA PUGH
Represented By
Jerome Dale Goldberg
Law Office
contact info
Amicus Curiae
MICHIGAN ATTORNEY GENERAL DANA NESSEL
Represented By
Ann M. Sherman
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Christopher Mark Allen
Michigan Department of Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
WILLIAM PEARSON, State School Reform/Redesign Officer
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
RICHARD SNYDER, Governor
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
JOHN C. AUSTIN, member of the MI Bd of Education
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
MICHELLE FECTEAU, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
LUPE RAMOS-MONTIGNY, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
PAMELA PUGH, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Jerome Dale Goldberg
Law Office
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
KATHLEEN N. STRAUS, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
CASANDRA E. ULBRICH, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
EILEEN WEISER, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
RICHARD ZEILE, member of the MI Bd of Ed
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
BRIAN J. WHISTON, Superintendent of Public Instruction for the State of MI
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
DAVID B. BEHEN, Director of the MI Dept of Techology
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
NATASHA BAKER, State School Reform/Redesign Officer
Represented By
Joshua Sean Smith
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
GRETCHEN WHITMER, Governor
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
TOM MCMILLIN, member of the MI Bd of Education
Represented By
Travis Comstock
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Bernard Eric Restuccia
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Elizabeth Briggs
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
JUDITH PRITCHETT, member of the MI Bd of Education
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
NIKKI SNYDER, member of the MI Bd of Education
Represented By
Travis Comstock
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Bernard Eric Restuccia
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Elizabeth Briggs
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
TIFFANY TILLEY, member of the MI Bd of Education
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
SHEILA ALLES, Interim Superintendent of Public Instruction for the State of MI
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
TRICIA L. FOSTER, Director of the MI Dept of Technology
Represented By
Tracy E. Van Den Bergh
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Neil Anthony Giovanatti
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Raymond O. Howd
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Toni L. Harris
Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
JESSIE K., a minor, by Yvette K., guardian ad litem
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
JAIME R., a minor by Karen R. guardian ad litem
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
PAUL M.
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
ESMERALDA V., a minor by Laura V., guardian ad litem
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
ISAIAS R., a minor by Escarle R., guardian ad litem
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
CHRISTOPHER R., a minor by Escarle R., guardian ad litem
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant
GARY B.
Represented By
Carter Glasgow Phillips
Sidley Austin
contact info
Bruce A. Miller
Miller Cohen
contact info
Jennifer Martin Wheeler
Sidley Austin
contact info
Tacy Fletcher Flint
Sidley Austin
contact info
Mark E. Haddad
University of Southern California
contact info
Evan Howard Caminker
University of Michigan Law School
contact info
Kathryn Eidmann
Law Office
contact info
Mark D. Rosenbaum
Law Office
contact info
Michael C. Kelley
Sidley Austin
contact info
Lawrence Fogel
Sidley Austin
contact info
Joshua Eugene Anderson
Sidley Austin
contact info
Proposed Intervenor
MICHIGAN SENATE
Represented By
John J. Bursch
Alliance Defending Freedom
contact info
Proposed Intervenor
MICHIGAN HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
Represented By
John J. Bursch
Alliance Defending Freedom
contact info

GPO Apr 23 2020
OPINION and JUDGMENT filed : The district court???s dismissal of Plaintiffs??? equal protection and compulsory-attendance due process claims is AFFIRMED, its dismissal of their due process claim based on the fundamental right to a basic minimum education is REVERSED, and the case is REMANDED for further proceedings consistent with the opinion of this court. Decision for publication. Eric L. Clay (AUTHORING), Jane Branstetter Stranch, and Eric E. Murphy (DISSENTING), Circuit Judges. [18-1855, 18-1871]

Docket last updated: 06/12/2020 3:31 AM CDT
Wednesday, August 01, 2018
The case manager for this case is: Leon Korotko. (LTK)
Related: [-]
3 pgs Civil Case Docketed. Notice filed by Appellants Gary B., Jessie K., Paul M., Christopher R., Isaias R., Jaime R. and Esmeralda V.. Transcript needed: y. (LTK)
Related: [-]