Alasaad, et al v. Mayorkas, et al

Original Case: 1:17-cv-11730

First Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
Case #:	0:20-civil-01081
Type	civil / us a party civil case / civil rights
Nature of Suit	440 Civil Rights - Other Civil Rights

Case Filed:	Jan 29, 2020
Terminated:	Feb 09, 2021

Last checked: Wednesday Feb 10, 2021 3:44 AM EST

Defendant - Appellant/Cross-Appellee MATTHEW T. ALBENCE, Acting Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Scott R. McIntosh US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info Joshua Paul Waldman US Dept of Justice contact info
Defendant - Appellant/Cross-Appellee MARK A. MORGAN, Acting Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Scott R. McIntosh US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info Joshua Paul Waldman US Dept of Justice contact info
Defendant - Appellant/Cross-Appellee CHAD F. WOLF, Acting Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Scott R. McIntosh US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info Joshua Paul Waldman US Dept of Justice contact info
Defendant - Appellee CHAD WOLF, Acting Secretary of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info
Defendant - Appellee MARK A. MORGAN, Acting Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info
Defendant - Appellee MATTHEW T. ALBENCE, Acting Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, in his official capacity	Represented By Marsha S. Edney US Dept of Justice contact info Michael Drezner US Dept of Justice contact info Donald Campbell Lockhart US Attorney's Office contact info Annapurna Balakrishna US Attorney's Office contact info
Interested Party CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY CENTER	Represented By David J. Nathanson Wood & Nathanson LLP contact info
Interested Party BRENNAN CENTER FOR JUSTICE AT NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW	Represented By Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party CENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY	Represented By Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party R STREET INSTITUTE	Represented By Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party KNIGHT FIRST AMENDMENT INSTITUTE AT COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY
Interested Party REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae TECHFREEDOM	Represented By Calvin Cohen Covington & Burling LLP contact info Kurt Wimmer Covington & Burling LLP contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Frank Broomell Covington & Burling LLP contact info Rafael Reyneri Covington & Burling LLP contact info Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae BRENNAN CENTER FOR JUSTICE AT NEW YORK UNIVERSITY SCHOOL OF LAW	Represented By Calvin Cohen Covington & Burling LLP contact info Kurt Wimmer Covington & Burling LLP contact info Frank Broomell Covington & Burling LLP contact info Rafael Reyneri Covington & Burling LLP contact info Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CENTER FOR DEMOCRACY & TECHNOLOGY	Represented By Calvin Cohen Covington & Burling LLP contact info Frank Broomell Covington & Burling LLP contact info Rafael Reyneri Covington & Burling LLP contact info Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae R STREET INSTITUTE	Represented By Calvin Cohen Covington & Burling LLP contact info Kurt Wimmer Covington & Burling LLP contact info Frank Broomell Covington & Burling LLP contact info Rafael Reyneri Covington & Burling LLP contact info Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CONSTITUTIONAL ACCOUNTABILITY CENTER	Represented By Brian R. Frazelle Constitutional Accountability Center contact info Brianne J. Gorod Constitutional Accountability Center contact info David J. Nathanson Wood & Nathanson LLP contact info Elizabeth B. Wydra Constitutional Accountability Center contact info Dayna Zolle Constitutional Accountability Center contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae HARVARD IMMIGRATION AND REFUGEE CLINICAL PROGRAM	Represented By Christopher T. Bavitz Cyberlaw Clinic, Harvard Law School contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF CRIMINAL DEFENSE LAWYERS	Represented By Michael J. Iacopino Brennan Lenehan Iacopino & Hickey contact info Mukund Rathi contact info Michael William Price National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE - CHICAGO	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NEW ENGLAND MUSLIM BAR ASSOCIATION	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae FIRST AMENDMENT COALITION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae FREEDOM OF THE PRESS FOUNDATION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae INTERNATIONAL DOCUMENTARY ASSOCIATION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae INVESTIGATIVE REPORTING WORKSHOP	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae KNIGHT FIRST AMENDMENT INSTITUTE AT COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY	Represented By Caroline DeCell Columbia University contact info Stephanie Krent Columbia University contact info Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MEDIA INSTITUTE	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NATIONAL PRESS PHOTOGRAPHERS ASSOCIATION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NEW ENGLAND FIRST AMENDMENT COALITION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NEWS LEADERS ASSOCIATION	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae PEN AMERICAN CENTER, INC.	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM OF THE PRESS	Represented By Katie Townsend Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info Caitlin Vogus Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info Linda Moon Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info Gabriel Rottman contact info Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SOCIETY OF ENVIRONMENTAL JOURNALISTS	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SOCIETY OF PROFESSIONAL JOURNALISTS	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae TULLY CENTER FOR FREE SPEECH	Represented By Bruce D. Brown Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae FLOYD ABRAMS	Represented By David A. Schulz Yale Law School contact info Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info Jennifer Pinsof Columbia University contact info Joshua Dunn Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae JACK M. BALKIN	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae HANNAH BLOCH-WEBAH	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae KIEL BRENNAN-MARQUEZ	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae M. RYAN CALO	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae DANIELLE KEATS CITRON	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae JULIE E. COHEN	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CATHERINE CRUMP	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MARY ANNE FRANKS	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae WOODROW HARTZOG	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae HEIDI KITROSSER	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae GREGORY MAGARIAN	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NEIL M. RICHARDS	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SCOTT SKINNER-THOMPSON	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae DANIEL J. SOLOVE	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae AMIE STEPANOVICH	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae KATHERINE J. STRANDBURG	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ARI EZRA WALDMAN	Represented By Elizabeth A. Ritvo Brown Rudnick LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae AMERICAN-ARAB ANTI-DISCRIINATION COMMITTEE (ADC)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ARAB RESOURCE & ORGANIZIN CENTER (AROC)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ASIAN AMERICAN LEGAL DEFENSE AND EDUCATION FUND	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE (AAJC)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE - ASIAN LAW CAUCUS	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae ASIAN AMERICANS ADVANCING JUSTICE - ATLANTA	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CAGE UK	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CENTER FOR CONSTITUTIONAL RIGHTS	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae COUNSIL ON AMERICAN-ISLAMIC RELATIONS (CAIR)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae CREATING LAW ENFORCEMENT ACCOUNTABILITY & RESPONSIBILITY (CLEAR)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae DEFENDING RIGHTS & DISSENT	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae IRANIAN AMERICAN BAR ASSOCIATION (IABA)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae JETPAC	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae JUSTICE FOR MUSLIMS COLLECTIVE	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae LATINOJUSTICE PRLDEF	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MPOWER	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MEDIA ALLIANCE	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MUSLIM ADVOCATES	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae MUSLIM JUSTICE LEAGUE	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae NATIONAL IMMIGRATION LAW CENTER	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae OAKLAND PRIVACY	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae PARTNERSHIP FOR THE ADVANCEMENT OF NEW AMERICANS (PANA)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SECURE JUSTICE	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SIKH COALITION	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae SOUTH ASIAN AMERICANS LEADING TOGETHER (SAALT)	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Interested Party - Amicus Curiae YEMENI ALLIANCE COMMITTEE	Represented By Meghan Koushik WilmerHale LLP contact info Glenn Katon Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Hammad Arsalan Alam Asian Americans Advancing Justice - Asian Law Caucus contact info Mark Christopher Fleming WilmerHale LLP contact info
Plaintiff TECHFREEDOM	Represented By Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Matthew S. Shapanka Covington & Burling LLP contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant GHASSAN ALASAAD	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant SUHAIB ALLABADIDI	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant SIDD BIKKANNAVAR	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant JEREMIE DUPIN	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant AARON GACH	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant ISMAIL ABDEL-RASOUL, a/k/a Isma'il Kushkush	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant DIANE MAYE ZORRI	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant ZAINAB MERCHANT	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant MOHAMMED AKRAM SHIBLY	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant MATTHEW WRIGHT	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellant NADIA ALASAAD	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant ISMAIL ABDEL-RASOUL, a/k/a Isma'il Kushkush	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant GHASSAN ALASAAD	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant NADIA ALASAAD	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant SUHAIB ALLABABIDI	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant SIDD BIKKANNAVAR	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant JEREMIE DUPIN	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant AARON GACH	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant ZAINAB MERCHANT	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant MOHAMMED AKRAM SHIBLY	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant MATTHEW WRIGHT	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee/Cross-Appellant DIANE MAYE ZORRI	Represented By Esha Bhandari American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Nathan Wessler American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Matthew R. Segal American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Hugh Handeyside American Civil Liberties Union Foundation contact info Saira Hussain Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Jessie J. Rossman American Civil Liberties Union of Massachusetts contact info Sophia Sabrina Cope Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Adam Schwartz Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info Aaron Mackey Electronic Frontier Foundation contact info

	GPO Feb 09 2021 OPINION issued by Sandra L. Lynch, Appellate Judge; Bruce M. Selya, Appellate Judge and Joseph N. Laplante,**. U.S. District Judge. Published. **Of the District of New Hampshire, sitting by designation [20-1077, 20-1081]. CLERK'S NOTE: Docket entry was edited to modify the docket text.
	GPO Feb 18 2021 ERRATA issued by court to opinion (published) [6400647-2]. [20-1077, 20-1081]

Docket last updated: 02/10/2021 3:44 AM EST

Wednesday, January 29, 2020
		Public docket note: Chad Wolf was sworn in as Secretary of Homeland Security on November 13, 2019. We have substituted him for Acting Secretary Elaine Duke, as the appellee. Mark A. Morgan was sworn in as Commissioner of U.S. Customs and Border Protection on July 5, 2019. We have substituted him for Acting Commissioner Kevin McAleenan, as the appellee. Matthew Albence was sworn in as Director of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement on July 5, 2019. We have substituted him for Acting Director Thomas Homan, as the appellee. 20-1081 (RMK) Related: [-]
		CIVIL CASE docketed. Notice of appeal (doc. #117) filed by Appellants Ismail Abdel-Rasoul, Ghassan Alasaad, Nadia Alasaad, Suhaib Allabadidi, Sidd Bikkannavar, Jeremie Dupin, Aaron Gach, Zainab Merchant, Mohammed Akram Shibly, Matthew Wright and Diane Maye Zorri. Docketing Statement, Transcript Report/Order form, and Appearance form due 02/12/2020. 20-1081 (RMK) Related: [-]
		Att: 1 80 pgs Abbreviated Record
		Att: 2 5 pgs Case Opening Notice
		Att: 3 1 pgs Notice Regarding Native PDF

Continue to Create Account