Original Case: 1:20-cv-08924

Second Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
Case #: 0:21-cv-01316
Typecivil / private
Nature of Suit440 Civil Rights - Other Civil Rights
Case Filed:May 19, 2021
Terminated:Mar 04, 2022
Last checked: Monday Mar 07, 2022 3:30 AM EST
Defendant
NYPD Sergeant Doe Caraballo
Defendant
Andre Jeanpierre, in his individual capacity
Defendant
Debora Matias, in her individual capacity
Defendant
Alfredo Jeff, in his individual capacity
Defendant
Umid Karimov, in his individual capaicty
Defendant
Ismael Hernandez Carpio, NYPD Police Officer, Shield #19759
Defendant
Mayor Bill de Blasio
Defendant
Police Commissioner Dermot Shea
Defendant
Chief of Department Terence Monahan
Defendant
City of New York
Defendant
NYPD Officerrs John Doe 1-32
Defendant
NYPD Officers Jane Doe 1-2
Defendant
NYPD Officer Doe Rivera
Defendant
NYPD Officer Doe Husband
Defendant
NYPD Sergeant Doe Manning
Defendant
Kenneth C. Lehr, in his individual capacity
Defendant
Sergeant Keith Cheng
Defendant
Lieutenant Michael Butler
Defendant
Officer Matthew Tarangelo
Defendant
Officer Thomas E. Manning
Defendant
Sergeant Gypsy Pichardo
Defendant
Officer Matthew L. Perry
Defendant
Lieutenant Thomas R. Hardell
Defendant
Officer Damian Rivera
Defendant
Officer Aaron Husbands
Defendant
Officer Jacqueline Vargas
Defendant
Joseph Deck
Defendant
Officers John Doe 1-26
Defendant
Officer Jane Doe 1
Defendant
Officer Doe Esposito
Defendant
Fausto Pichardo
Defendant
NYPD Officers John and Jane Does 1-40
Defendant
Kevin Agro, NYPD Officer, Shield No. 8054
Defendant
Talha Ahmad, NYPD Officer, Shield No. 21358
Defendant
Edward Carrasco, NYPD Detective, Shield No. 1567
Defendant
John/Jane Does 1-10
Defendant
New York City Police Department
Defendant
Police Officer Wells
Defendant
Police Officer Lars Frantzen
Defendant
Fierro, Shield No. 88189
Defendant
Richardo, 40th Precinct
Defendant
Eduard Lucero
Defendant
Scott Haldeman
Defendant - Appellant
Police Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc.
Represented By
Robert S. Smith
Law Offices of Robert S. Smith
contact info
Richard H. Dolan
Schlam Stone & Dolan LLP
contact info
Thomas A. Kissane
Schlam Stone & Dolan LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Jacqueline Vargas
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Sergeant Keith Cheng
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Mayor Bill de Blasio
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
City of New York
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Lieutenant Michael Butler
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Joseph Deck
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Police Commissioner Dermot Shea
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Chief of Department Terence Monahan
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Matthew Tarangelo
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Thomas E. Manning
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Sergeant Gypsy Pichardo
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Matthew L. Perry
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Lieutenant Thomas R. Hardell
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Damian Rivera
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Defendant - Appellee
Officer Aaron Husbands
Represented By
MacKenzie Fillow
New York City Law Department
contact info
Petitioner
Jon Brodie
Plaintiff
Kayla Roland
Plaintiff
Corey Gilzean
Plaintiff
Michael Hernandez
Plaintiff
Christopher Husary
Plaintiff
Keith Clingman
Plaintiff
Jonathan Peck
Plaintiff - Appellee
Colleen McCormack-Maitland
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Vivian Matthew King-Yarde
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Nicholas Mulder
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Julian Philips
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Micaela Martinez
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Jaime Fried
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Charlie Monlouis-Anderle
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Vidal Guzman
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Camila Gini
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Andie Mali
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Jarrett Payne
Represented By
Corey Stoughton
The Legal Aid Society
contact info
Christopher Thomas Dunn
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Molly Biklen
American Civil Liberties Union Foundation
contact info
Robert Hodgson
New York Civil Liberties Union
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
David Jakevic, on behalf of themselves and othes similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Savitri Durkee, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Dara Pluchino, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Maria Salazar, on behalf of themselves and others simillarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Sabrina Zurkuhlen
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Matthew Bredder
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Barbara Ross, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Oscar Rios, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Alexandra de Mucha Pino, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Masai I. Lord
Lord Law Group, PLLC
contact info
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Jonathan Clifford Moore
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Wylie M. Stecklow
Wylie Stecklow PLLC
contact info
Jessica Massimi
Jessica Massimi, Esq.
contact info
Elena Louisa Cohen
Elena L. Cohen, Esq.
contact info
Gideon Orion Oliver
Gideon Orion Oliver, Attorney at Law
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Cameron Yates
Represented By
Andrew B. Stoll
Stoll, Glickman & Bellina LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Alex Gutierrez, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated
Represented By
Joshua Moskovitz
The Law Office of Joshua Moskovitz, P.C.
contact info
Michael L. Spiegel
Michael L. Spiegel, Esq.
contact info
Lance A. Clarke
Hamilton Clarke, LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Ricardo Nigaglioni, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated
Represented By
Joshua Moskovitz
The Law Office of Joshua Moskovitz, P.C.
contact info
Michael L. Spiegel
Michael L. Spiegel, Esq.
contact info
Lance A. Clarke
Hamilton Clarke, LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Amali Sierra, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated
Represented By
Joshua Moskovitz
The Law Office of Joshua Moskovitz, P.C.
contact info
Michael L. Spiegel
Michael L. Spiegel, Esq.
contact info
Lance A. Clarke
Hamilton Clarke, LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Samira Sierra, individually and on behalf of all others similarly situated
Represented By
Joshua Moskovitz
The Law Office of Joshua Moskovitz, P.C.
contact info
Michael L. Spiegel
Michael L. Spiegel, Esq.
contact info
Lance A. Clarke
Hamilton Clarke, LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Adama Sow, on behalf of themselves and others similarly situated
Represented By
Luna Droubi
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Remy Green
Cohen & Green P.L.L.C.
contact info
Jonathan Clifford Moore
Beldock Levine & Hoffman LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
People of the State of New York
Represented By
Barbara D. Underwood
New York State Office of the Attorney General
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
Charles Henry Wood
Represented By
Douglas Edward Lieb
Kaufman Lieb Lebowitz & Frick LLP
contact info

GPO Mar 04 2022
OPINION, reversing the district courtâ??s denial of intervention with respect to the actions seeking declaratory or injunctive relief. Affirming the district courtâ??s denial of intervention with respect to those actions that seek neither declaratory nor injunctive relief, by DAL, DJ, SJM, FILED.[3271606] [21-1316]

Docket last updated: 03/07/2022 3:28 AM EST
Wednesday, May 19, 2021
1 1 NOTICE OF CIVIL APPEAL, with district court docket, on behalf of Appellant Police Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., FILED. [3105657] 21-1316 [Entered: 05/21/2021 01:46 PM]
Related: [-]
Att: 1 2 pgs Dkt_Ntc_BK_CV_PR_Tax
Att: 2 46 pgs Case FILED
2 2 19 pgs DISTRICT COURT MEMORANDUM DECISION AND ORDER, dated 04/28/2021, RECEIVED.[3105668] 21-1316 [Entered: 05/21/2021 01:51 PM]
Related: [-]
3 3 PAYMENT OF DOCKETING FEE, on behalf of Appellant Police Benevolent Association of the City of New York, Inc., district court receipt # NYSDC-24562108, FILED.[3105673] 21-1316 [Entered: 05/21/2021 01:52 PM]
Related: [-]