Florida Northern District Court
Judge:Robert L Hinkle
Referred: Martin A Fitzpatrick
Case #: 4:21-cv-00220
Nature of Suit950 Other Statutes - Constitutionality of State Statutes
Cause42:1983 Civil Rights Act
Case Filed:May 27, 2021
Case in other court:USSC, 22-00277
Last checked: Tuesday Nov 23, 2021 3:29 AM EST
Amicus
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
Represented By
DAVID ALLEN GREENE
Electronic Frontier Foundation - San Francisco Ca
contact info
KURT BRADFORD OPSAHL
Electronic Frontier Foundation - San Francisco Ca
contact info
AARON DAVID MACKEY
Electronic Frontier Foundation - San Francisco Ca
contact info
Amicus
WASHINGTON CENTER FOR TECHNOLOGY POLICY INCLUSION
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
TECHNET
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
TECHFREEDOM
Represented By
BERIN MICHAEL SZOKA
Tech Freedom - Washington Dc
contact info
LAWRENCE G WALTERS
Walters Law Group - Longwood Fl
contact info
Amicus
REPORTERS COMMITTEE FOR FREEDOM OF THE PRESS
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
PROGRESSIVE POLICY INSTITUTE
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
PEN AMERICAN CENTER INC
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
NATIONAL BLACK JUSTICE COALITION
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
MEDIA LAW RESOURCE CENTER INC
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
INTERNET ASSOCIATION
Represented By
ARI HOLTZBLATT
Wilmer Hale - Washington Dc
contact info
PETER WINSLOW HOMER
Homer Bonner
contact info
PAUL R WOLFSON
Wilmer Hale - Washington Dc
contact info
PATRICK J CAROME
Wilmer Hale - New York Ny
contact info
Amicus
INFORMATION TECHNOLOGY & INNOVATION FOUNDATION
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
LEONID GOLDSTEIN
Amicus
ENGINE ADVOCACY
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
CONSUMER TECHNOLOGY ASSOCIATION
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
CHAMBER OF PROGRESS
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Amicus
CENTER FOR DEMOCRACY AND TECHNOLOGY
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
AUTHORS GUILD INC
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION OF FLORIDA
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
AMERICAN CIVIL LIBERTIES UNION
Represented By
DEANNA K SHULLMAN
Shullman Fugate Pllc - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Amicus
CONNECTED COMMERCE COUNCIL
Represented By
NURY AGUDO SIEKKINEN
Zwillgen Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
Defendant
JONI ALEXIS POITIER
Represented By
GLEN ALLEN BASSETT
contact info
DANIEL WILLIAM BELL
Florida Attorney Generals Office
contact info
BLAINE H WINSHIP
Office Of The Attorney General - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
Defendant
JASON TODD ALLEN
Represented By
GLEN ALLEN BASSETT
contact info
DANIEL WILLIAM BELL
Florida Attorney Generals Office
contact info
BLAINE H WINSHIP
Office Of The Attorney General - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
Defendant
PATRICK GILLESPIE
Represented By
CHARLES JUSTIN COOPER
Cooper & Kirk Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
BRIAN WESLEY BARNES
Cooper & Kirk Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
JAMES WILLIAM UTHMEIER
Executive Office Of The Governor Of Florida
contact info
DAVID HENRY THOMPSON
Cooper & Kirk Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
JOSEPH MASTERMAN
Cooper & Kirk Pllc - Washington Dc
contact info
RAYMOND FREDERICK TREADWELL
Executive Office Of The Governor
contact info
Defendant
JOHN MARTIN HAYES
Represented By
GLEN ALLEN BASSETT
contact info
DANIEL WILLIAM BELL
Florida Attorney Generals Office
contact info
BLAINE H WINSHIP
Office Of The Attorney General - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
Defendant
ASHLEY BROOKE MOODY
Represented By
GLEN ALLEN BASSETT
contact info
DANIEL WILLIAM BELL
Florida Attorney Generals Office
contact info
BLAINE H WINSHIP
Office Of The Attorney General - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
Defendant
KYMBERLEE CURRY SMITH
Represented By
GLEN ALLEN BASSETT
contact info
DANIEL WILLIAM BELL
Florida Attorney Generals Office
contact info
BLAINE H WINSHIP
Office Of The Attorney General - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
Interested Party
Protect Democracy Project, Inc.
Represented By
CHRISTOPHER BENTON HOPKINS
Mcdonald Hopkins Co Pa - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Interested Party
ELECTRONIC FRONTIER FOUNDATION
Represented By
DAVID ALLEN GREENE
Electronic Frontier Foundation - San Francisco Ca
contact info
KURT BRADFORD OPSAHL
Electronic Frontier Foundation - San Francisco Ca
contact info
CHRISTOPHER BENTON HOPKINS
Mcdonald Hopkins Co Pa - West Palm Beach Fl
contact info
Plaintiff
NETCHOICE LLC
Represented By
JOSEPH TRUMON PHILLIPS
Dla Piper Us Llp - Tampa Fl
contact info
LAUREN GALLO WHITE
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - San Francisco Ca
contact info
BRIAN M WILLEN
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - New York Ny
contact info
JONATHAN ALLEN GREEN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
DANIELLE T MORRISON
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
BEN FABENS-LASSEN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
PETER KARANJIA
Dla Piper Us Llp - Washington Dc
contact info
MENG JIA YANG
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - Palo Alto Ca
contact info
STEFFEN N JOHNSON
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - Washington Dc
contact info
CHRISTOPHER GEORGE OPRISON
Dla Piper Us Llp - Miami Fl
contact info
ILANA HOPE EISENSTEIN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
Plaintiff
COMPUTER & COMMUNICATIONS INDUSTRY ASSOCIATION
Represented By
JOSEPH TRUMON PHILLIPS
Dla Piper Us Llp - Tampa Fl
contact info
BRIDGET KELLOGG SMITHA
Stearns Weaver Miller Etc Pa - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
JONATHAN ALLEN GREEN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
MENG JIA YANG
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - Palo Alto Ca
contact info
CHRISTOPHER ROY CLARK
Stearns Weaver Miller - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
ILANA HOPE EISENSTEIN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
GLENN T BURHANS, JR
Stearns Weaver Miller Etc Pa - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
LAUREN GALLO WHITE
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - San Francisco Ca
contact info
BRIAN M WILLEN
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - New York Ny
contact info
DOUGLAS LAMAR KILBY
Ausley Mcmullen - Tallahassee Fl
contact info
DANIELLE T MORRISON
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
BEN FABENS-LASSEN
Dla Piper Us Llp - Philadelphia PA
contact info
PETER KARANJIA
Dla Piper Us Llp - Washington Dc
contact info
STEFFEN N JOHNSON
Wilson Sonsini Goodrich Etc - Washington Dc
contact info
CHRISTOPHER GEORGE OPRISON
Dla Piper Us Llp - Miami Fl
contact info

GPO Jun 30 2021
ORDER granting 22 Motion for Preliminary Injunction. Signed by JUDGE ROBERT L HINKLE on 6/30/2021. (RH)

Docket last updated: 04/20/2025 11:59 PM EDT
Friday, April 18, 2025
utility Action Required by Magistrate Judge - No NEFs in SEALED Cases Fri 04/18 7:14 AM
ACTION REQUIRED BY MAGISTRATE JUDGE: Chambers of MAGISTRATE JUDGE MARTIN A FITZPATRICK notified that action is needed Re:199 MOTION to Appear Pro Hac Vice by Clark Hildabrand.( Filing fee $ 219 receipt number AFLNDC-9442467.). Referred to MARTIN A FITZPATRICK. (sjb)
Related: [-]
Thursday, April 17, 2025
199 199 motion Appear Pro Hac Vice Thu 04/17 4:08 PM
MOTION to Appear Pro Hac Vice by Clark Hildabrand.( Filing fee $ 219 receipt number AFLNDC-9442467.) by JONI ALEXIS POITIER, CHAD MIZELLE, CARLOS LOPEZ-CANTERA, MARVA PRESTON, RICK JOYCE, JOHN MARTIN HAYES, KYMBERLEE CURRY SMITH. (HILDABRAND, CLARK)
Related: [-]
Att: 1 Exhibit A - Certificate of Good Standing,
Att: 2 Exhibit B - NY Order
Tuesday, April 15, 2025
198 198 notice Notice of Hearing on Motion Tue 04/15 9:03 AM
NOTICE OF HEARING ON ALL PENDING MOTIONS (173 ,191 ,196 Motions): Motion Hearing set for 5/6/2025 at 9:00 AM before JUDGE ROBERT L HINKLE, Joseph Woodrow Hatchett United States Courthouse and Federal Building, Courtroom 5 East, 111 North Adams St., Tallahassee, Florida 32301. NOTE: If you or any party, witness or attorney in this matter has a disability that requires special accommodation, such as a hearing impairment that requires a sign language interpreter or a wheelchair restriction that requires ramp access, please contact Cindy Markley at 850-521-3518 in the Clerk's Office at least one week prior to the hearing (or as soon as possible) so arrangements can be made. s/ Cindy Markley Courtroom Deputy Clerk. (ckm)
Related: [-]
Monday, April 14, 2025
197 197 respm Response in Opposition to Motion Mon 04/14 9:22 PM
RESPONSE in Opposition re191 MOTION to Compel Discovery filed by NETCHOICE LLC. (KILBY, DOUGLAS)
Related: [-]
196 196 motion Extend Time Mon 04/14 1:58 PM
MOTION to Extend Time Unopposed Motion to Modify Schedule by JONI ALEXIS POITIER, CHAD MIZELLE, CARLOS LOPEZ-CANTERA, MARVA PRESTON, RICK JOYCE, JAMES UTHMEIER, JOHN MARTIN HAYES, KYMBERLEE CURRY SMITH. (GOLEMBIEWSKI, KEVIN)
Related: [-]
Saturday, April 12, 2025
195 195 9 pgs order Order Mon 04/14 8:29 AM
PROTECTIVE ORDER. Signed by JUDGE ROBERT L HINKLE on 4/12/2025. (rcb)
Related: [-]