Arizona District Court
Judge:John J Tuchi
Case #: 2:22-cv-01431
Nature of Suit950 Other Statutes - Constitutionality of State Statutes
Cause42:1983 Civil Rights Act
Case Filed:Aug 23, 2022
Terminated:Jul 21, 2023
Last checked: Sunday Feb 19, 2023 3:31 AM MST
Amicus
Southern Arizona NLG
Represented By
Adam Daniel Schwartz
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Molly Brizgys
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Kathleen E Brody
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Mukund Rathi
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Amicus
Poder in Action
Represented By
Adam Daniel Schwartz
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Molly Brizgys
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Kathleen E Brody
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Mukund Rathi
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Amicus
Mass Liberation AZ
Represented By
Adam Daniel Schwartz
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Molly Brizgys
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Kathleen E Brody
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Mukund Rathi
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Amicus
Electronic Frontier Foundation
Represented By
Adam Daniel Schwartz
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Molly Brizgys
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Kathleen E Brody
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Mukund Rathi
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Amicus
Central Arizona NLG
Represented By
Adam Daniel Schwartz
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Molly Brizgys
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Kathleen E Brody
Mitchell Stein Carey Chapman PC
contact info
Mukund Rathi
Electronic Frontier Foundation
contact info
Amicus
Associated Press
Represented By
Zachary Robert Cormier
Tiffany & Bosco PA
contact info
Gregg Paul Leslie
Asu Sandra Day Oconnor College Of Law
contact info
Defendant
Mark Brnovich
Represented By
Brunn Wall Roysden, III
Office Of The Attorney General - Phoenix
contact info
Robert John Makar
Office Of The Attorney General - Phoenix
contact info
Defendant
Rachel Mitchell
Represented By
Joseph I Vigil
Maricopa County Attorney Civil Services Division
contact info
Joseph James Branco
Maricopa County Attorney Civil Services Division
contact info
Defendant
Paul Penzone
Represented By
Joseph I Vigil
Maricopa County Attorney Civil Services Division
contact info
Joseph James Branco
Maricopa County Attorney Civil Services Division
contact info
Plaintiff
Telemundo of Arizona LLC
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
States Newsroom/Arizona Mirror
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Scripps Media Incorporated
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Phoenix Newspapers Incorporated
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
National Press Photographers Association
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
KPNX-TV
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Gray Media Group Incorporated
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Fox Television Stations LLC
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Arizona Newspapers Association
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
Arizona Broadcasters Association
Represented By
Kennison C Lay
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
David Jeremy Bodney
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Plaintiff
American Civil Liberties Union of Arizona
Represented By
Shreya Tewari
Aclu - New York, Ny
contact info
Vera Eidelman
Aclu - New York, Ny
contact info
K M Bell
Aclu - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Jared G Keenan
Aclu - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Esha Bhandari
Aclu - New York, Ny
contact info
Matthew E Kelley
Ballard Spahr Llp - Phoenix, Az
contact info
Benjamin Leigh Rundall
Aclu - Phoenix, Az
contact info

GPO Sep 09 2022
ORDER: IT IS ORDERED granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Preliminary Injunction (Doc. 24). The Court enjoins the enforcement of A.R.S. § 13-3732 pending further order. (See attached Order). Signed by Judge John J Tuchi on 9/9/2022. (JAMA)

Docket last updated: 11/03/2024 11:59 PM MST
Friday, July 21, 2023
69 69 1 pgs order Order Fri 07/21 2:56 PM
ORDER - IT IS HEREBY ORDERED Defendant Kris Mayes, in her official capacity of Attorney General for the State of Arizona, shall pay Plaintiffs the total sum of $69,000.00 at the conclusion of this litigation. Of that total, $23,000.00 shall be paid to Plaintiff ACLU of Arizona and $46,000 shall be paid to the News Media Plaintiffs in care of their attorneys, Ballard Spahr LLP. Such payment shall be in full settlement of any claims by Plaintiffs for attorneys' fees and costs in this matter. Signed by Judge John J Tuchi on 7/21/2023. (WLP)
Related: [-]
68 68 order Judgment - Default Fri 07/21 2:53 PM
ORDER FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION AND DECLARATORY JUDGMENT; DEFAULT JUDGMENT AS TO COUNTY DEFENDANTS - IT IS FURTHER ORDERED granting Plaintiffs' Motion for Default Judgment against Defendants Rachel Mitchell, in her official capacity as Maricopa County Attorney, and Paul Penzone, in his official capacity as Maricopa County Sheriff (Doc.56 ). IT IS FURTHER ORDERED granting the Stipulation Regarding Entry of Permanent Injunction and Declaratory Judgment (Doc.66 ). IT IS FURTHER ORDERED denying as moot Plaintiffs' Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings against Defendant Kristin K. Mayes, in her official capacity as Attorney General for the State of Arizona (Doc.54 ). IT IS FURTHER ORDERED directing the Clerk to close this matter. See document for complete details. Signed by Judge John J Tuchi on 7/21/2023. (WLP)
Related: [-]