Original Case: 1:13-cv-00734

D.C. Circuit U.S. Court of Appeals
Case #: 0:23-cvus-05238
Typecivil us / united states
Nature of Suit440 Civil Rights - Other Civil Rights
Case Filed:Oct 19, 2023
Terminated:Feb 16, 2024
Last checked: Tuesday Feb 20, 2024 4:07 AM EST
Defendant - Appellant
Internal Revenue Service
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Michael Seto, In his official and individual capacity as Acting Manager, Technical Unit, IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
David Fish, In his official and individual capacity as Acting Director, Office of Rulings & Agreements, IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Steven Grodnitzky, In his official and individual capacity as Manager, Exempt Organizations Technical Unit, IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Cindy M. Thomas, In her official and individual capacity as Program Manager, Exempt Organizations Determinations Unit of the IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Holly Paz, In her official and individual capacity as Acting Manager, Exempt Organizations Technical Unit, Acting Director, Office of Rulings & Agreements, And Director, Office of Rulings & Agreements, IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
William Wilkins, In his official and indivdual capacity as Chief Counsel, Internal Revenue Service
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Daniel I. Werfel, In his official capacity as Commissioner of the Internal Revenue Service
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Unknown Named Employees of Internal Revenue Service, In their official and individual capacities
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Faye Ng, In her official and individual capacity as an Exempt Organizations Sepcialist, IRS
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Eric Richard Nitz
MoloLamken LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Janine L. Estes, In her official and individual capacity as an Exempt Organizations Specialist, IRS
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Eric Richard Nitz
MoloLamken LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Susan Maloney, In her official and individual capacity as an Exempt Organizations Specialist, IRS
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Eric Richard Nitz
MoloLamken LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Ronald Bell, In his official and individual capacity as an Exempt Organizations Specialist, IRS
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Eric Richard Nitz
MoloLamken LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Lois Lerner, In her official and individual capacity as Director, Exempt Organizations Division, IRS
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Douglas H. Shulman, In his individual capacity
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
Steven T. Miller, In his official and Indivicual capacity as former Deputy Commissioner, Services & Enforcement, and Acting Commissioner, Internal Revenue Service
Represented By
Brigida Benitez
Steptoe LLP
contact info
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Defendant - Appellant
United States of America
Represented By
Geoffrey Klimas
U.S. Department of Justice
contact info
Interested Party - Appellee
Public Interest Legal Foundation, Inc.
Represented By
Kaylan Lytle Phillips
Public Interest Legal Foundation
contact info
Noel Henry Johnson
Public Interest Legal Foundation
contact info
Interested Party - Appellee
Bopp Law Firm, PC
Represented By
James Bopp Jr.
The Bopp Law Firm, PC
contact info
Interested Party - Appellee
Foley and Lardner, LLP
Represented By
Michael J. Lockerby
Foley & Lardner LLP
contact info
Plaintiff - Appellee
True the Vote, Inc.
Represented By
Michael John Wynne
Gregor Wynne Arney, PLLC
contact info


Docket last updated: 02/20/2024 4:07 AM EST
Thursday, October 19, 2023
US CIVIL CASE docketed. 23-5238
Related: [-]
30+ pgs NOTICE OF APPEAL [2022728] seeking review of a decision by the U.S. District Court in 1:13-cv-00734-RBW filed by Ronald Bell, Janine L. Estes, David Fish, Steven Grodnitzky, IRS, Lois Lerner, Susan Maloney, Steven T. Miller, Faye Ng, Holly Paz, Michael Seto, Douglas H. Shulman, Cindy M. Thomas, USA, Unknown Named Employees of Internal Revenue Service, Daniel I. Werfel and William Wilkins. Appeal assigned USCA Case Number: 23-5238 23-5238
Related: [-]